Details of SRA Voting

 Total Area Votes

 

Kalk Bay

St. James

KB + St.J

Total votes in SRA

556.00

323.00

879.00

Total residential votes

492.00

287.00

779.00

Total commercial votes

64.00

36.00

100.00

Residential / Commercial %

88.5/11.5

88.9/11.1

88.7/11.3

 

 

 

 

Total votes required

333.00

194.000

527.00

Total ‘yes’ votes obtained

356.00

210.00

566.00

Percentage ‘yes’ votes

64.03

65.02

64.39

Residential / Commercial %

91/9

90.5/9.5

90.75/9.25

 

 

 

 

Total ‘no’ votes

23.00

15.00

38.00

‘No’ votes % of total in SRA

4.10

4.60

4.30

‘No’ votes % of votes cast

6.10

6.70

6.30

‘No’ votes Residential / Commercial

17/6

11/4

28/10

Majestic, Kalk Bay

Total votes            112 residential  /  3 commercial
Votes cast              52 residential / 3 commercial / 1 negative
% voting                47.8% positive / 1% negative

If the Majestic is removed altogether:

Total votes in SRA for Kalk Bay  :  556 – 115 = 441
Total ‘yes’ votes obtained would be  :  356 – 55 = 301
% ‘yes’ votes  :  301 / 441 * 100  =  68.2

Fisherman’s Flats

Available votes        54
Positive votes          44
Negative votes           6
Abstentions               4

% Positive votes      81.5
% Negative votes    11.1

 

Kalk Bay

St. James

KB + St.J

Total votes in SRA

556.00

323.00

879.00

Total residential votes

492.00

287.00

779.00

Total commercial votes

64.00

36.00

100.00

Residential / Commercial %

88.5/11.5

88.9/11.1

88.7/11.3

 

 

 

 

Total votes required

333.00

194.000

527.00

Total ‘yes’ votes obtained

356.00

210.00

566.00

Percentage ‘yes’ votes

64.03

65.02

64.39

Residential / Commercial %

91/9

90.5/9.5

90.75/9.25

 

 

 

 

Total ‘no’ votes

23.00

15.00

38.00

‘No’ votes % of total in SRA

4.10

4.60

4.30

‘No’ votes % of votes cast

6.10

6.70

6.30

‘No’ votes Residential / Commercial

17/6

11/4

28/10

Extended Area for the KBSJ SRA

News Bulletin No. 2

1.  Results of voting on the SRA proposal

Following the public meeting held on 22 July at which the Business Plan and Budget of the proposed SRA were explained, a team of canvassers proceeded to approach property owners in the intended SRA for their votes, positive or negative, on the SRA proposal. In order for the City Council to consider a proposal for the intended SRA, the approval of owners who own at least 60% by number of rateable properties in the intended SRA had to be obtained.

The canvassers were allocated specific areas to cover and great efforts were made to contact as many property owners as possible.

The result of these canvassing efforts is that 566 “yes” votes were obtained (subject to Council verification) out of a total of 879 votes. This is 64.39% of the total number of votes and safely exceeds the required majority of 60%.  [Details of the votes]

Highlights of the voting results include the following:

  • The required positive threshold of 60% was exceeded in both St James and Kalk Bay. Views on the proposal were consistent in both areas.
  • The percentage of “no” votes of the total votes received was 6.3%.
  • Of the owners of units at the Fisherman’s Flats, 81.5% voted in favour (vs. 11.1% “no” votes) clearly indicating that this section of our community is strongly in favour of the proposal.
  • Difficulty was experienced in obtaining e-mail response and votes from the majority of unit owners at the Majestic complex, most of whom do not live locally. Consequently only about 50% of available votes were obtained from this section of our community. Clearly this community needs to understand that participation in wider community initiatives is in their best interests.
  • If the votes for the Majestic are excluded, the majority vote would increase to 68.2%

Sincere thanks to all canvassers for their efforts and also to everyone who voted, whether positive or negative. Your community spirit is much appreciated.

In view of the positive outcome of the voting process, an application for the establishment of the SRA was filed with the City Council on 29 October.

2.  Extended area

The Steering Committee was approached during October to extend the boundary of the intended SRA in a westerly direction along Main Road in order to include the 16 properties (21 votes) on the mountain side of Main Road up to and including Erf 90123.

As is made clear in the Motivation Report, inclusiveness of all of our village is a very strong principle of our community. The Steering Committee attempted to reflect this principle in the delineation of the boundaries. However, in order to ensure that our proposed budget would be able to service the intended SRA adequately, it was originally decided to set the boundary at Quarry Road.

Nevertheless, in view of the small additional number of properties (about 3%) and the fact that these properties are included on the locality map and property data sheet sent to us by the City Council as being included in Kalk Bay, the Steering Committee agreed to include these properties in our application provided at least 60% of votes from these properties were obtained by Sunday 3 November.

The City Council also agreed to this minor extension of the SRA area on this basis.

The 11 required votes were collected in time and delivered to the Council, as arranged, on Wednesday 6 November. In accordance with Council requirements, the SRA will now be referred to as KBSJ SRA (Extended Area).

3.  Process going forward

  • The application will be advertised for objections on 15 November 2013.
  • Notices calling for objections will be sent to property owners by the end of November 2013.
  • Meetings with objectors will be held during December and January to discuss their objections.
  • A second public meeting will be held on Monday 27 January 2014 to inform all attendees of relevant information pertaining to the application, and to discuss practical implications relating to the application.
  • The objection period will close on 7 February 2014.
  • 31 March 2014: City Council decides on application.
  • April, May, June: prepare for start of operations: elect board, appoint contractors etc.
  • 1 July 2014: SRA commences operations.

Clarifications

News Bulletin No. 1

Members of the Steering Committee have received a few queries in the following respects.

1.  More details on the services to be provided

Safety and Security:

We have two firm quotations from security companies to provide a foot patrol security service in respect of the public spaces in the SRA (i.e. pavements, parks, etc) on a 24 hours a day basis. Services from the currently favoured service provider would include:

  • The provision of four security guards per shift. This could be adjusted to, for example, five during the day and three at night or whatever is agreed with the SRA Company.
  • Spotter personnel on the mountain would work in conjunction with the patrol guards.
  • The security company’s personnel in its patrol vehicle, who provide services to private clients, would also maintain contact with the foot patrol guards, on the understanding that private clients would have priority to the services of the   motorized personnel.
  • A trained dog unit could also be utilized by the security company if required.
  • Existing CCTV security cameras mounted in public spaces would also be utilized by the security company in their overall service.

The proposed security budget of R800,000 provides ample scope for 24 hour security patrols, but as is made clear in the Business Plan, a more detailed overall strategy regarding safety and security must still be formulated.  Also, the SRA Company will more precisely determine the scope and timing of these services as they gain experience.  This might include an approach that includes the temporary deployment of a higher proportion of foot patrol guards to identified “hot spots” from time to time.

As is also mentioned in the Business Plan, the SRA Company will work closely with the appointed security company and local law enforcement agencies (SAPS, SA National Parks etc) to co-ordinate law enforcement and security activities.

As mentioned at the public meeting, the Steering Committee is also investigating supplementary initiatives to promote community safety (for example trained personnel to identify potential problem areas or suspicious activity) at as low a cost as possible within the overall budget allocation.

Litter and Cleanliness and Maintenance of Public Spaces:

One full time worker will concentrate on these activities in Kalk Bay and a part time worker will concentrate on the St James area. These activities will supplement the services provided by the City Council and private initiatives in respect of such areas such as the Lever Street Park.

A more detailed strategy is still to be formulated on these issues, which might include the periodic focus on “hot spots” in addition to routine maintenance.

Social Services:

It is envisaged that the services of a trained social worker will be contracted on a part time basis (two or three days per week) to provide a service that would include:

  • Assistance to try to re-connect vagrants and street children with their families
  • Assistance to acquire disability and similar grants
  • Assistance  with rehabilitation work opportunities
  • Etc

Again, a more detailed strategy is to be formulated in this regard.

2.  Clarification on other SRA boundaries

Some people who attended the public meeting on 22 July 2013 have commented that the SRA proposal the presenters created the impression that the entire area of Muizenberg and Fish Hoek are included within approved SRAs and/or that these SRAs are primarily residential.

It was not the intention to create this impression. The intention was to emphasize that 26 SRAs have been approved by the City Council, and these include both commercial and primarily residential areas, and that Muizenberg and Fish Hoek are among the approved SRAs.

The Muizenberg SRA’s boundaries are demarcated by Main Road from Muizenberg Station in the south to the junction of Albertyn Road in the north, then in a north easterly direction along Albertyn Road and round Vlei Road up to Beach Road and along the beach front back to Muizenberg Station. The SRA is primarily a residential area and residential property owners contribute somewhat more than commercial property owners to the SRA budget.

Interest has been expressed by residents in areas adjacent to the SRA with a view to receiving the benefits of the SRA, and possibly joining the SRA.

The Fish Hoek SRA is concentrated in the area of the Main Road. It extends from the Clovelly traffic lights to the traffic circle at the Simonstown end of the Main Road, and includes Beach Road, Main Road, First Avenue and specific blocks in Second and Third Avenue.  This SRA is primarily commercially based, although this SRA also includes a significant proportion of residential properties.

3.  Rates Rebates

According to its 2013/2014 budget, the City Council provides the following rates rebates:

Pensioners and disabled ratepayers:  A rebate is allowed to pensioners aged over 60 years and disabled ratepayers in receipt of a disability pension, in either case whose gross household income does not exceed R12,000.00 per month and who occupy the property as his/her primary residence, provided that where the owner is unable to occupy the property due to no fault of his/her own, the spouse or children may satisfy the occupancy requirement.  The amount of the rebate is on a sliding scale depending on the level of earnings.

Indigent ratepayers:  According to the City Council a rates rebate is also available for ratepayers earning less than R4,000.00 per month after tax.

In either case, the rebate is applied on application.  In this respect, application forms can be obtained from the council offices in Fish Hoek (speak to Chantelle Edwards).

As is mentioned in the Business Plan, if any ratepayer receives a rates rebate, he/she will be 100% exempt from payment of any additional SRA rates.

Public Meeting

Public Information Meeting to be held on 22nd July 2013

Pursuant to informal approval of a proposal made at the AGM of the Kalk Bay/St James Residents and Ratepayers Association in May 2012 to explore the possibility of establishing a Special Rates Area in Kalk Bay and St James, a steering committee of local residents conducted a perception survey in November 2012 to identify the needs and priorities of residents.

This survey indicates that the majority of residents appear to support the establishment of an SRA for their area. The steering committee has accordingly prepared a proposed business plan and budget based on the outcome of the perception survey.  An information meeting is planned to be held in the Kalk Bay Community Hall, Main Road, on 22nd July to explain the proposal to property owners in the intended SRA. Formal notice of this meeting will appear in the press during July.

Thereafter, if a majority of 60% of property owners support the proposal it will be sent the City of Council for their consideration and approval.  If this is obtained, it is planned that the SRA will become operational in July 2014.